Starting January 1, 2027, California will begin restricting the sale of certain dietary supplements, including creatine products, to anyone under 18.
Yes, you read that correctly. You could soon be asked to show your ID to purchase creatine.
California Assembly Bill 2030, signed into law in September 2026, restricts the sale of over-the-counter diet pills and dietary supplements marketed for weight loss or muscle building to anyone under 18 without a prescription.
Even 100% Pure Creatine Monohydrate?
Yes. Even plain, 100% creatine monohydrate falls under California’s new restrictions.
It doesn’t have to contain stimulants, questionable ingredients, or anything other than creatine.
If the product is marketed for muscle building, it falls under the new law. That means retailers may ask for ID to verify you’re 18 or older.
Yes, you read that right!
As a personal trainer and nutrition coach with 20 years of fitness industry experience, I think California is missing the mark on creatine.
First, Why Is California Doing This?
Supporters argue that certain weight-loss and muscle-building supplements, including products containing creatine, are associated with eating disorders, body dysmorphia, depression, and other mental health concerns among teenagers.
Meanwhile, teenagers are spending hours scrolling through social media, comparing themselves to filtered photos, unrealistic physiques, and influencers promoting impossible body standards. But sure, let’s focus on creatine!
There are also concerns about misleading marketing, potentially harmful stimulants, and products promising rapid muscle gain or extreme weight loss.
And I agree. Those are legitimate concerns.
But here’s my problem: Creatine is NOT a dangerous diet pill, an anabolic steroid, or a stimulant. It doesn’t cause rapid fat loss or magically build muscle overnight. And there’s no convincing evidence that creatine itself causes eating disorders or body dysmorphia.
There’s a big difference between a supplement being associated with unhealthy body-image behaviors and that supplement actually causing those behaviors.
Lumping creatine together with potentially dangerous weight-loss and muscle-building products makes very little sense to me.
1. Creatine Is Being Studied for Its Potential Benefits for Depression
Here’s something I find especially interesting.
While lawmakers are concerned about associations between supplement use and depression, researchers are studying creatine as a potential way to HELP improve depressive symptoms.
A 2025 systematic review and meta-analysis published in the British Journal of Nutrition examined 1,093 participants across 11 clinical trials.
Researchers found that creatine improved depressive symptoms; although the overall benefit was small, it was still a benefit.
Another review published in 2026 found promising results when creatine was combined with certain depression treatments, but emphasized that larger studies are still needed.
Let me be clear: Creatine is not an established treatment for depression. But the emerging research is interesting and, so far, very positive, especially given creatine’s role in cellular energy production and brain function.
That’s why I think we need to look at individual ingredients and the actual science, rather than treating all muscle-building supplements as equally concerning.
Read the research:
- Creatine Supplementation for Treating Symptoms of Depression — PubMed, 2025
- The Effect of Creatine Monohydrate on Mental Disorders — PubMed, 2026
2. But Teenagers Can Still Buy Energy Drinks?
A teenager can walk into a convenience store in California and purchase an unlimited amount of energy drinks loaded with caffeine without a statewide age-verification requirement.
Yet certain creatine supplements will now be age-restricted.
How does that make sense?
We’re talking about a supplement that has been extensively researched for decades, primarily for its benefits in exercise performance, strength, and muscle recovery.
Creatine itself is not a stimulant. It doesn’t give you the caffeine rush you get from an energy drink.
And unlike highly caffeinated drinks, plain creatine monohydrate doesn’t work by stimulating your central nervous system.
I’m not saying teenagers should be drinking energy drinks, either. In fact, excessive caffeine consumption among young people is a legitimate health concern.
I’m asking why California is prioritizing creatine restrictions while energy drinks remain available without a comparable statewide age limit.
3. Creatine Isn’t Going to Build Muscle or Melt Fat Overnight!
Another concern behind these restrictions is that teenagers will build too much muscle and lose too much weight too quickly.
And I get it. Social media has created completely unrealistic expectations about how fast someone can transform their body.
But let’s get something straight.
Taking creatine won’t magically put 20 pounds of muscle on your body or melt away 20 pounds of fat.
That’s simply not how it works.
Creatine helps your muscles produce energy during short bursts of high-intensity exercise, allowing you to potentially train harder, improve performance, and build strength over time.
But you still have to put in the work!
You still need to lift weights, eat properly, recover, and most importantly, stay consistent. Creatine doesn’t replace any of that.
And as far as rapid weight loss? Creatine isn’t even a fat-loss supplement! In fact, some people initially see the number on the scale go UP because creatine increases water retention within the muscles.
Creatine isn’t a shortcut to a dramatic body transformation. It’s a supplement that can support the work you’re already doing.
4. If We’re So Concerned About Rapid Body Changes, What About Peptides?
Here’s another question.
Some local nutrition shops are selling peptides without even asking customers for ID. That means a teenager could walk in and buy products marketed for fat loss, muscle growth, or injury recovery.
And we’re worried about creatine?
Unlike creatine, which has been around for over 100 years and extensively studied for over 35 years, with decades of research supporting its safety and effectiveness in healthy adults, many of these peptides are experimental and have limited human safety data.
My Final Thoughts
I’ve been in the fitness industry for over 20 years, and I’ve seen plenty of supplement trends come and go.
Most are overhyped, overpriced, and a waste of money. But a few actually live up to the hype.
Creatine is one of them.
It’s one of the most extensively researched sports supplements available, with decades of science supporting its benefits for strength, muscle performance, and high-intensity exercise. Promising research also suggests potential benefits for brain health and cognitive function.
Does that mean every teenager needs to take creatine? Absolutely not.
Should teenagers be taking supplements without proper guidance? No.
And should we ignore the very real concerns surrounding eating disorders and body image? Of course not.
But I believe education, parental involvement, and science-based decisions are far more productive than treating every muscle-building supplement as though it carries the same risks.
For those wondering, I personally take plain creatine monohydrate. Nothing fancy, no unnecessary ingredients. Just creatine. You can find the exact one I use HERE.
So here’s my question: Are we actually protecting teenagers, or are we creating unnecessary restrictions around one of the most researched supplements on the market?
I’d love to hear your thoughts!
Do you agree with California requiring age verification for certain creatine products, or do you think this law goes too far?
— Aftann
Personal Trainer & Nutrition Coach | aftannFIT


